I think it would be good if you could post the respective images
Mine is
Looks: 9
Functionality: 8
Reliability: 9
Price: 7
Characteristics:
1Gb Mp4 player, 1.5' screen, with built in speakers (one in each side).
Two front buttons (loop & Play/Pause), one middle joystick with four directions and pressing function.
It has a "record" button on the right side, as well as an "on/off" button, though it's useless as it resets the player's clock if you turn it off in that way... (The other and most common way to shut it off is pressing for a while the Play button)
Good things:
* The joystick makes easier the navigation between different menues
* The speakers are useful if you are at home, or another not-crowdy place
* The ability to charge the built-in battery via USB port or AAC plug
Not so good things:
* Slow interface
* Boring games (Boxman-Tetris-Winmine-Colorbeads)
* When you stop a song, you have to wait until the "stop" button appears, then you can access the menu
* Weird commands (i.e: To go up or down the menues, you have to pull the joystick left & right)
* Price: 125 USD$
Still not tested: Lyrics support
As I've said before, those items are "not so good things" so even if they are present, they don't affect too much the score given to the player, which qualifies for "Excellent"