[lattesurf]

princessanne1026 , good on ya!
At least you paid $28 for a 512MB player don't seem all too bad for it. Seriously I don't think you can buy a 512MB player for this price in your local shops?
I did a google search on his userid, how cool.. 126 search results on this guy alone! And all are negative results!

Regarding the feedback thing, it's totally upto you to leave +ve, -ve or neutral.
If i were in your shoes, i'll probably give him +ve (but maybe a neutral? somewhere in between). But the comments won't be that nice, at least he still offered a $10 refund. Most others in this forum and many others out there don't even get a reply (much less a partial refund) from their sellers.